Skip to content

weird behaviour of service and media player

I have an activity that starts and binds to a music playing service, hence I have implemented both the onStartCommand and onBind methods. I have a MediaPlayer object in the service used to play media files.

These are the steps I perform:

  1. I start the service and bind to it from the activity.
  2. the service invokes the MediaPlayer Object with a valid
    mediaLocation and the media starts playing
  3. I destroy the activity, while being destroyed, I use the
    unbindService(mServiceConn) method to unbind to the service, the
    media keeps playing
  4. I close the service, from it’s close button in the notification UI,
    which calls it’s stopSelf method, and remove the notification
    using the notificationManager.cancel(ID)
  5. At this point, since the service was both started and bound I
    have called both the unbind and stopSelf methods, so acc. to the android docs
    this would be enough to stop a started-bound service.
  6. The notification closes
  7. and the service‘s onDestroy also gets called(checked using
    Logcat outputs)
  8. yet the MediaPlayer keeps on playing the music

My confusion is, if the UI(activity) and notification both are destroyed, then shouldn’t the whole process be destroyed, hence making the MediaPlayer stop? Or is the service not destroyed, which is why the media is still being played?

I could work around the media being played by forceFully stopping it in the service‘s onDestroy or similar methods but how do I even know the service (and the process in it’s entirety) is all cleaned up? So, it’s not taking up any unseen resources?

PS.: The code was too long to post a runnable example, so no code was posted, yet mostly it’s just standard stuff, nothing from personal logic was added.

Answer

When you use media player to play music, the media player does not directly play the music, but requests the playback engine of the android system to play the music.
When you no longer use the playback engine of the android system, you should call the release() method of the media player to release system resources.